Idaho Senator Proposes Bill to Bar Religious or Cultural Law References in State Courts
Idaho Senator Proposes Bill to Bar Religious or Cultural Law References in State Courts
———————————–
Republican State Senator Dan Foreman has introduced a bill aimed at preventing Idaho courts from citing what he describes as “religious or cultural law” in legal proceedings, sparking debate and criticism over whether the proposal indirectly targets Islamic law.
Foreman described the legislation as a preventive measure designed to reaffirm the state’s constitutional principles and existing legal framework. He noted that, to his knowledge, no prior court decisions in Idaho have relied on religious laws. However, he argued that the absence of such cases does not preclude the possibility of them arising in the future, and the bill is intended to prevent any potential overlap between civil law and other legal or cultural frameworks.
In media statements, Foreman cited examples from other states, including Texas, to justify the proposal, saying that preemptive legislation is preferable to addressing hypothetical legal conflicts after they occur.
The bill was discussed in the Idaho Senate Judiciary and Rules Committee, where Republican Senator Brian Lenney referenced Islamic law, citing a legal case from New Jersey, although he acknowledged that the initial ruling in that case was later overturned.
Foreman emphasized that the bill does not target Islamic law or any specific religion, asserting that its stated purpose is to protect Idaho’s civil legal system and ensure courts adhere to the state’s established laws.
The proposal comes amid a broader national debate in the United States over the role of religion in law and whether measures like this strengthen constitutional principles or risk creating indirect discrimination against certain religious groups.
Civil rights advocates and legal experts have expressed concern that while the bill is framed as neutral, its focus on preventing the application of “religious or cultural law” could disproportionately affect minority religious communities.
